Increase minimum rank for Legion Founding
Author |
Message |
ICBLF
Joined: Sat Jul 02, 2011 6:52 pm Posts: 1663 Location: where the dead ships dwell
|

Uy23e wrote: Perhaps there could be two types of legion creation. One is directly founding of a legion, with a higher requirement The other is a "charter", where the leader must have a number of players to "sign up" before it can be created. This would have little to no requirement.
The only valid arguments "for" allowing lower rank to found a legion seems to be centered around finding a group of like ranked friends to do elites, and this would allow such a group to create a legion together, if they can gather enough to make that a valid reason. Otherwise, there is really no reason making new legions.
Granted, alt spam can still create a legion by oneself at low rank, but that'd be both against the rules and a lot of work for very little benefit. Doubt people would do that.
But yes, we can see what training does first before anything else. I like the charter idea. If someone bothers to alt one up, it's their own loss stagnating with a dozen of their soon to be banned multis. I think apart from that edge it provides a reasonable solution for the occasional group of low rankers who have a legitimate chance at a successful new legion.
_________________ 
|
Thu Nov 06, 2014 4:08 am |
|
 |
Malevolentia
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:47 am Posts: 841
|

ICBLF wrote: Uy23e wrote: Perhaps there could be two types of legion creation. One is directly founding of a legion, with a higher requirement The other is a "charter", where the leader must have a number of players to "sign up" before it can be created. This would have little to no requirement.
The only valid arguments "for" allowing lower rank to found a legion seems to be centered around finding a group of like ranked friends to do elites, and this would allow such a group to create a legion together, if they can gather enough to make that a valid reason. Otherwise, there is really no reason making new legions.
Granted, alt spam can still create a legion by oneself at low rank, but that'd be both against the rules and a lot of work for very little benefit. Doubt people would do that.
But yes, we can see what training does first before anything else. I like the charter idea. If someone bothers to alt one up, it's their own loss stagnating with a dozen of their soon to be banned multis. I think apart from that edge it provides a reasonable solution for the occasional group of low rankers who have a legitimate chance at a successful new legion. This does make sense. I agree, the charter idea sounds pretty cool. You could create a legion and then require a minimum number of members by the end of your first week or the legion gets dissolved. A week is plenty of time if you've got a group of low rankers. But there are legions out there with plenty of space for even the noobiest of noobs. Galaxy Battleships has 7 players under rank 50 and 14 players under rank 100. If we need a minimum of 10 people to make a legion, they're only going to be a tiny bit better off than GB in terms of their numbers of <R50 players. Or somewhere like Khanate of Ursa with 19 <R50 players. It's not difficult to find legions with plenty of players around your rank as is. With training legions coming about, participating legions will already have low rankers because of training slots. The reason, from what I can fathom, that the rank 30 requirement was put in place was that when legions were first released, we didn't have the same community then. I've seen posts from around the time they came out and there are people who are talking about how difficult the Sha'din A.I. Matrix is because people were just starting to find them for the first time (They are shareable with ranks 125 to 600). Among just the top 50 legions there are hundreds of players over rank 1000, let alone rank 500. The requirement doesn't even have to be as high as 500. Maybe 300 is more reasonable. 30 is still way too low.
_________________ 
|
Thu Nov 06, 2014 9:10 am |
|
 |
Malevolentia
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:47 am Posts: 841
|

Malevolentia wrote: DarkMar wrote: Malevolentia wrote: It's a bad idea, in your opinion, for the reason you gave in that thread which was refuted by myself. That is, even with a higher minimum rank requirement to make a legion there would be no reason that low rankers would struggle to find a legion with enough people to assist with alertable NPCs in their rank range. It's bad form to quote opinion as fact. I'm not quoting it as facts, I presume players actualy read the post I link to where they can also read your arguments for raising the rank needed to start a Legion difrence is, I'm not going to bother repeading it all here we dont disagrey, that startig a new legion is way to easy atm and a lot of new legions simply go inactive becourse they cant get anougth members but doesnt change the fact, that rank sets limits on NPC hunting and PvP shares for badges, so in most cases players will be better off in a legion with a lot of players in rougthly the same Badge and NPC range We definitely agree on starting a new legion being too easy, but imposing a higher rank limit of, say, 500 would not prevent a low ranker from joining a legion with more than enough players in their rank range, something which I have demonstrated to be true in the previous thread. It would force them into larger legions for the most part, as you won't get many legions with a R500 leader and just a handful of R<100s (so they'd be looking at legions like Khanate of Ursa, Hell Razors, Galaxy Battleships), but that's kind of the point of this suggestion; get everybody into larger legions where they don't whither away to nothing and leave out of boredom. I think I am leaning towards agreement for having an initial high cost for starting a legion. Perhaps remove the rank requirement altogether and instead of a CTP requirement introduce a very high energy cost. For example, it'll take a one-off shot of 5000 energy to found a new legion. This is an about-right energy bar for a R500 and introduces a sort of artificial soft-limit on rank, as noobs aren't going to have that kind of energy bar. Tri-Matrix Emblems and Energy Cubes aren't so absurdly rare that this could be considered unreasonable for someone who did have an energy bar of exactly 5000, where they might rank up, found a legion, and then if they didn't have an energy refill they would be stranded to the slow crawl of energy recharge for at the very least 28 hours but probably more like two days. With the context of energy cubes and tri-matrix emblems they should be fine with just a touch of forethought. I am going to quote this into the other thread as that one still has an actual title.
_________________ 
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 11:27 am |
|
 |
DarkMar
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 2:27 pm Posts: 1220
|

for me it not a Rank thing.... due to the fact that you can rougthly split NPC hunting into 3 to 4 categories
rank 900+ rank 500 to 1000 rank 50 to 600 (and this one could proberly be split in 2 as well. as most of the first elite/boss NPC you get disapear around rank 200)
to few members in one rank category, and they wont get the NPC's they should or have enougth players to fill a 10+ players boss but if you like NPC hunting, you can actualy do quite well, in a legion with mostly rank 200 to 600 members, where everyone can see everyones shares and a boss fills up in a few hours that's more or less what I had back at rank 500's in delta surfers, but had to leave them when we ended up with to few members beeing able to see Clusters and other high rank NPC's
you also have to look at extream slow ranking PvP ships, some of those can spendt months, if not years below rank 100 doing nothing but raiding, hacking and killing enemy ships to build up badges some of those might actualy be qualified to lead a PvP legion, even if they are "only" rank 100
a cost to start a new legion - CTP's or energy might work but as I have sayed before, what I would realy like to see, was a pre-request, that before you could start a legion yourself, you would need to spendt 14 to 30 days in a legion
_________________Champion of Darmos 
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 11:56 am |
|
 |
Deigobene
Joined: Tue Oct 16, 2012 9:26 pm Posts: 1076
|
Just sayin' - it is entirely possible to create and build a very good legion starting at a much earlier point than Rank 500
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 11:58 am |
|
 |
Malevolentia
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:47 am Posts: 841
|

DarkMar wrote: for me it not a Rank thing.... due to the fact that you can rougthly split NPC hunting into 3 to 4 categories
rank 900+ rank 500 to 1000 rank 50 to 600 (and this one could proberly be split in 2 as well. as most of the first elite/boss NPC you get disapear around rank 200)
to few members in one rank category, and they wont get the NPC's they should or have enougth players to fill a 10+ players boss but if you like NPC hunting, you can actualy do quite well, in a legion with mostly rank 200 to 600 members, where everyone can see everyones shares and a boss fills up in a few hours that's more or less what I had back at rank 500's in delta surfers, but had to leave them when we ended up with to few members beeing able to see Clusters and other high rank NPC's
you also have to look at extream slow ranking PvP ships, some of those can spendt months, if not years below rank 100 doing nothing but raiding, hacking and killing enemy ships to build up badges some of those might actualy be qualified to lead a PvP legion, even if they are "only" rank 100
a cost to start a new legion - CTP's or energy might work but as I have sayed before, what I would realy like to see, was a pre-request, that before you could start a legion yourself, you would need to spendt 14 to 30 days in a legion We're going to have to put the issue of rank range issues aside as we don't seem to be able to disagree. You perceive a problem which I don't think will actually be a problem and it doesn't seem we're getting anywhere with that discussion. Let's focus on other aspects of this idea. A time-spent-playing medal could work and it certainly has it's merits. I think even 30 days is a bit short. Something more like 180 days. At this stage in the game I don't think this is an unreasonable requirement. Team Player 20 Medal Points Collect a daily reward after spending 180 days as a loyal member of a legion **and earning the Back in my day... medal**. Reward: Base Construction Licence Base Construction Licence Grants you permission to found a new legion. No scrap available The bit in asterisks, that is earning the BIMD medal, is placed there for consideration as I think it could be a bit too out there... But I'm not sure. Given that the game is now, what, five years old? I don't think this is too unreasonable but would appreciate the opinions of others on this.
_________________ 
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 12:07 pm |
|
 |
Malevolentia
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:47 am Posts: 841
|

Deigobene wrote: Just sayin' - it is entirely possible to create and build a very good legion starting at a much earlier point than Rank 500 Possible? Sure. Likely? No. And it is worth considering that whilst someone may run a good legion themselves, that does not imply that they would not do well as a member of a larger legion run by other people. Although saying that, it seems that it has been taken into consideration and we are exploring other avenues of limiting the mass legion creation that seems to happen with low ranks who then find the game stagnant because nobody wants to join them. The basic theme of the idea is to impose limitations on legion creation to prevent the little nooblings of the game from making crappy little legions which get nowhere. Imposing these limitations should improve the overall health of the game. The problem will be quite majorly offset, however, by the way the new trainee system works. Noobs joining the game are much less likely to consider making their own legion because they are placed into one already which they may enjoy. Of course, on the flip side of this coin, many noobs are joining the game and being randomly assigned to crap legions, not good ones.
_________________ 
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 12:13 pm |
|
 |
DarkMar
Joined: Sun Feb 12, 2012 2:27 pm Posts: 1220
|

Malevolentia wrote: Team Player 20 Medal Points Collect a daily reward after spending 180 days as a loyal member of a legion **and earning the Back in my day... medal**. Reward: Base Construction Licence
Base Construction Licence Grants you permission to found a new legion. No scrap available
The bit in asterisks, that is earning the BIMD medal, is placed there for consideration as I think it could be a bit too out there... But I'm not sure. Given that the game is now, what, five years old? I don't think this is too unreasonable but would appreciate the opinions of others on this. something like that would work for me, but I think Quote: Back in my day... Collect a daily reward after playing Galaxy Legion for over 1 year. and Quote: Collect a daily reward after spending 180 days as a loyal member of a legion is a bit to high I think 3+ months spendt in game, and 30+ days as a loyal member of a legion would be enougth but that just numbers that can be tweaked up or down, depending on how hard you want to make it to start a new legion
_________________Champion of Darmos 
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 12:34 pm |
|
 |
Malevolentia
Joined: Tue May 21, 2013 2:47 am Posts: 841
|

DarkMar wrote: Malevolentia wrote: Team Player 20 Medal Points Collect a daily reward after spending 180 days as a loyal member of a legion **and earning the Back in my day... medal**. Reward: Base Construction Licence
Base Construction Licence Grants you permission to found a new legion. No scrap available
The bit in asterisks, that is earning the BIMD medal, is placed there for consideration as I think it could be a bit too out there... But I'm not sure. Given that the game is now, what, five years old? I don't think this is too unreasonable but would appreciate the opinions of others on this. something like that would work for me, but I think Quote: Back in my day... Collect a daily reward after playing Galaxy Legion for over 1 year. and Quote: Collect a daily reward after spending 180 days as a loyal member of a legion is a bit to high I think 3+ months spendt in game, and 30+ days as a loyal member of a legion would be enougth but that just numbers that can be tweaked up or down, depending on how hard you want to make it to start a new legion I thought it might be too high as well. 180 days is only ~6 months; I don't think that's unreasonable. Also, I'd like to clarify that this doesn't mean spend 180 days as a loyal member of the same legion all in one go.
_________________ 
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 12:38 pm |
|
 |
Deigobene
Joined: Tue Oct 16, 2012 9:26 pm Posts: 1076
|
Malevolentia wrote: Deigobene wrote: Just sayin' - it is entirely possible to create and build a very good legion starting at a much earlier point than Rank 500 Possible? Sure. Likely? No. Been done? Yep. My comment wasn't a hypothetical. Been there, done that, got the T-shirt. Same situation with Back in my day medal... I reached Rank 500 a couple of months before that, so I think that is way too long. Anyway, regardless of that, with the new trainee system I really don't know that it is that pressing an issue to be honest. As they always have, people will drop off, get bored, join crappy legions, have fun with their friends, try stuff for fun... it's all good really, it's a game not a job.
|
Sun Mar 01, 2015 1:37 pm |
|
 |
|
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 28 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|