Hi, so I built into a small ship build and have been gratuitously adding to my Tactical Officers. During combat, I have noticed my attack doesn't seem to be hitting quite as hard as I would think it should. I have taken a cross-section of hits versus other players as examples and evidence. I just want some feedback on this. I looked at the formulas for combat in the wiki and they seemed pretty wonky. Here are the pics of the fights I used as a reference point.

My current deck isze is 342, making my maximum non-crit damage roughly 170. I want to know why people with fractions of my attack and similar defense are hitting my damage cap or close to it and I can't scratch them, when they are way larger than I am in size and they still have minimal defense. Phoenix12 was also about 100 decks larger than I am.